Consumer Commission Rules JioMart Wallet Refund a 'Dark Pattern'
The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission in Panchkula has ruled that JioMart’s practice of crediting refunds to a reward wallet constitutes a deceptive 'dark pattern.' The commission ordered Reliance Retail to pay Rs 7,500 after the platform sent Re 1 of a customer's refund to a wallet instead of her original payment method, despite prior assurances.
A consumer commission in India has ordered Reliance Retail to pay Rs 7,500 after determining that JioMart’s practice of directing refunds into a reward wallet rather than the original payment method constitutes a deceptive trade practice. The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission in Panchkula issued the order on October 28, holding both Reliance Retail Limited and Reliance Smart Superstore liable for deficiency in service.
The case centered on a customer who received only Re 1 of her refund into a JioMart reward wallet, contrary to the platform's representation that the full amount would be returned via the original mode of payment. The commission stated that consumers cannot be compelled to accept wallet credit when refunds have been promised through their initial payment channel.
In its ruling, the commission explicitly linked this practice to "dark patterns," noting that directing funds into a platform-specific wallet may induce consumers to make additional purchases on the same site. The order cited the Central Consumer Protection Authority’s (CCPA) 2023 Guidelines for Prevention and Regulation of Dark Patterns as relevant regulatory context.
Reliance appeared before the commission through legal counsel but failed to file a written statement despite multiple opportunities. Consequently, the commission struck off its defense on June 26. Both entities have been given 45 days to comply with the payment order.
While the Consumer Protection (E-Commerce) Rules of 2020 mandate that platforms process accepted refunds within a reasonable timeframe, they do not strictly define the required payment method for those refunds. However, regulatory scrutiny in this area has intensified. In 2024, the CCPA directed ride-hailing service Ola to offer customers a choice between bank refunds and coupons after finding it had exclusively provided coupon codes.
According to a Lok Sabha reply from August, the CCPA has imposed penalties totaling approximately Rs 1.12 crore on 47 e-commerce platforms for dark pattern violations. Thirty-one platforms have since declared compliance with the authority's guidelines.
R.Martini--GdR